Avoiding Empty Calorie Excess

 Guest Post By Donna Smith

Call it what you will, munching, carb loading, fulfilling a craving, snacking, having a treat … it’s all the same thing …. Taking on excess calories.  Of course, if we only reached for carrots or apples to meet this “need,” then it really wouldn’t be a problem.  But the food that usually appears in our hands and subsequently in our mouths is more typically chips, ice cream, cookies, candy, etc.  Do we enjoy this?  Yes.  Have we been inundated since early childhood by advertising to do just this?  Absolutely.  Is it smart, thoughtful, useful, beneficial to our bodies in any way?  Hardly!  Other sources address the “why” of this behavior.  This article addresses ways to control it so that it no longer subverts our efforts to achieve fitness.

 First, take a close look at what you eat every day.  Just write down all that you eat.  Next, look at what you are doing while you’re eating, (e.g., sitting at the dining table, working at your desk, watching TV, browsing the web.)  Your list might look something like this:

  • Cereal, coffee and juice, 7:00 a.m., sitting at the dining table
  • Coffee and doughnut, 8:00 a.m., grabbed in the break room and taken to my desk
  • Soda, 9:30 a.m., at my desk
  • Sandwich and chips with soda, noon, eating with colleagues
  • Soda, 1:00 p.m., taken back to my desk after lunch
  • Coffee and M&M’s, 2:30 p.m., at my desk trying to get an energy boost
  • A beer and a couple of jalapeño poppers with friends after work
  • Chicken, rice, squash and broccoli, 7:00 p.m., sitting at the dining table
  • Popcorn and soda, 8:30 p.m., sitting on the couch watching TV
  • Milk and cookies, 10:00 p.m., getting ready for bed and watching the local news

 

Looking at this all written out makes you want to say, “I don’t eat like that.  That’s way too much food!”  But I am willing to bet that if you’re concerned about those pants which just don’t fit like they use to, that your list, if you’re honest with yourself, will be very similar.  Pick up an old grocery receipt and really look at what’s on it.  Look at what’s on your kitchen shelves or in your refrigerator.  Large or small, the behavior is there.

 Once you’ve made such a list, cross out the meals and then look at what’s left.  This is the part that contains most of the excess empty calories (i.e., the calories that have little to no nutritional value and serve no purpose for your body except to pack on extra weight.) 

 Once you clearly recognize and acknowledge this behavior in yourself, then you can work to change it.  Here are some tips that can help you make this change.

  • Keep a list going every day.  Believe me, your conscious mind doesn’t want to keep seeing that junk on your list.
  • Start reading the nutrition facts about the extra foods you choose to put in your mouth.  Read the package or check it out online. 
  • Once you know what’s in the food you are thinking about eating, ask yourself, “what does this do for me?”

 

After you have repeated the above steps enough, you can boil all of this down to one simple question.  “Is eating this food a smart choice?”  If the answer is “no,” then consider taking another action.  Here are some tips on other actions.

  • Choose to eat something else to which the answer to the “smart choice” question is “yes!”  Try fruit, yogurt, nuts or seeds, a protein drink, an energy bar or some other small snack that you know to have nutritional value (i.e., something that feeds your body with protein or vitamins.)
  • If you’re not really hungry, then do something else.  A lot of this munching behavior is driven by the need to be doing something in addition to or other than what you’re already doing.  Find something to do with your hands … crafts, crossword puzzles, games, web-surfing, etc.  At work I keep a star-shaped slinky on my desk and when I feel the need to reach out and grab something, I pick it up and run it through my hands till the urge passes.  It’s much better for me than M&M’s and co-workers love to play with it, too.  At home I crochet to keep my hands busy while watching TV.  It’s all about finding something to do instead of picking up worthless food and putting it into your mouth.

 Here are a couple more tricks to break this unconscious behavior.

  • Don’t keep that kind of food in the house or office.  This can be a problem if you live or work with others who don’t have the same commitment to improve eating habits, but see what adjustments you can make.  You don’t have to stock the foods that really tempt you.  If chocolate is your thing, then buy cookies for the family, but don’t buy chocolate cookies.  Minimize your bad options so that at 10:00 at night when you find yourself in the kitchen looking for something to munch, there just isn’t anything there that’s bad for you.
  • Choose the time when it’s okay (i.e., the least damaging to your fitness and health), to eat the things you really like.  If you really love ice cream, then use it as a treat for yourself after you’ve gone a whole week without excess eating. I definitely like sweets and so I limit myself to only eating sweets that are really very good and therefore worth expending the empty calories.  This means that I don’t munch doughnuts just because someone brought them into the office, but if we go out for lunch to a restaurant that has great tiramisu, then I let myself have it.  But it has to be really great as opposed to just on the menu!

 

Finally, no discussion of consuming empty calories is complete without discussing alcohol.  When, where, what and why you drink alcohol is your own business and not the topic of this article.  Being aware of calorie intake when you drink alcohol, is.  Hard liquor ranges from 25 to 110 calories per shot, and liqueurs are closer to 150.  Mixed drinks really start to escalate caloric intake and those with several kinds of alcohol, sweeteners and whipped cream start to rival rich desserts for calories.  16 ounces of beer averages around 200 calories and 4 ounces of wine ranges from 65 to 100 calories.  The important thing to remember here is notwithstanding claims of benefits to health from wine, these are all empty calories, and should be given the same choice test above for eating snack food.  Any perfectly nutritionally balanced day topped off with consuming 500 calories of alcohol will result in weight gain.  But don’t take my word for it, just step on your scales!

 We’re talking about replacing a bad habit with deliberate action to improve fitness.  It’s not easy, but it is the smart thing to do.  There are basically three steps:

  1. Identify and define the behavior of consuming excess, empty calories for yourself.
  2. Identify what triggers this behavior.
  3. Either eliminate the trigger or replace the behavior it triggers with something more beneficial to your health.

 

The goal is to be able to say, “I make smart choices about what I eat!”

P90X-Take 2

Back in September of last year, I decided to try out the increasingly popular workout DVD, the p90x. At the time, I thought I was ready to make the commitment, but as I soon found out, I wasn’t. I ended up staying on the 90-day program for about 40 days.

The program was tough and I wasn’t physically (or mentally) up for the challenge, but things have changed and it’s time for another go. I have decided to try my hand at Tony Horton’s workout program once more and have set my goals.

I am planning on doing only the first 2 phases of the program (3 weeks + 3weeks + 1 week of recovery in between) to drop 10 pounds and then plan to switch to a heavy lifting schedule to add back the weight with muscle. My start weight is 178.5 pounds.

I will not be chronicling my progress this time, so feel free to submit a comment and I will be glad to share my progress.

Demystifying Functional Training

It seems that there is an awful lot of confusion when it comes to the term ‘functional training’. I have found that most of the non-fitness industry folks I’ve spoken to about this seem to think that functional training is some sort of advanced form of exercise for athletes or entails a specific sport. While this term can be applied to a specific sport or activity, the broad meaning is quite a bit different.

Functional training is basically a form of strength training which is used to enhance the performance and ease of completing activities of daily living (ADL).  Such activities would be bending (to pick up your child), reaching (for that last jelly donut in the back of …oh wait), jumping, walking, climbing stairs, twisting, you get the idea…

The goal of this type of training is to teach your nervous system to become more efficient at interacting with your muscular system. The way this is done is by choosing exercises which replicate movements of ADL’s. Performing movements in all  three planes of motion is key to this form of training. The three planes are frontal, sagittal, and transverse.

Examples of each are:

  • Frontal plane-bicep curl
  • Sagittal plane-lateral shoulder raises
  • Transverse plane-standing side twists

Functional training is important for all, but even more so for aging adults. As we get older, our bodies begin to break down and movement decreases. Picking up your keys off the ground have caused numerous lower back injuries. Turning in your car seat to yell at your kids has been cause for more than a few neck injuries. Falling down trying to climb up or down stairs are sources of common injuries as well.

My belief is that along with strength and cardio training, functional training should be a part of an exercise program in which the client has the goal of maintaining mobility and reducing the likelihood of injuries. Um..I guess that’s everyone…

Functional training will address flexibility, core, balance, and coordination issues which are all extremely important components of a proper exercise program.

Here are a few exercises which I will classify as functional training:

  • Squats
  • Lunges
  • Woodchops
  • Resistance band rotations
  • Stability Ball exercises
  • BoSu Exercises

For videos of functional training exercises as well as plenty of quality articles, you can visit LiveStrong.com. It’s a very good site with tons of good information.

12 Useless Fitness Gadgets

As a follow up to my last article about push up equipment, I wanted to share my thoughts on useless fitness equipment that has found its way onto our closet shelves by means of deceptive and false advertising.

With billions of dollars spent each year in the health an fitness industry, there is a vast market of opportunity for businesses looking to capitalize on a country full of overweight people.  We have become an ”I want it now” society” , so is it any wonder that these companies are producing merchandise that promises fast results with little or no effort? Quick results sells and long and difficult doesn’t! That’s it..

Over the last decade I have seen numerous fitness products making great claims about their health benefits, but unfortunately not too many can back it up with science. In my opinion, here are some of the culprits which are tarnishing the reputation of the fitness industry and wasting our hard earned money:

1. The Ab Lounger: Cost: $75-$100. This was one of the more popular pieces of shit equipment found on late night television and subsequently became very popular. Any time your body is stabilized, you are shortchanging the effectiveness of the movement. That’s exactly what this thing does. A basic crunch is more effective and a whole lot cheaper.

2. Commercial Crunch Machine: Cost: $1,000-$2,000. Have you ever seen someone using all their might trying to crunch the whole stack of weight on this machine? I have and it’s not pretty. They are probably thinking that the more weight they can crunch, the better their abs will look, right? You’re more likely to strain your neck or back that you are to get ripped abs. How about doing a few core exercises on a stability ball instead.

3. BodyBlade: Cost: $50-$200: This contraption claims that instead of using resistance training or free weights, the vibrating blade is all you need. Supposedly it works all of your muscles by vibrating 270 times per minute and helps improve your coordination and balance. I can’t see how this thing can have any significant effect at all or why anyone would buy it. Makes no sense to me….

4. Electronic Ab Belt: Cost: $30-$60: Electronic impulses are sent to your abdominal muscles and produce contractions, which in turn will build strength and improve fat loss. This is one of their claims. Hmmmmm. The only exercise you will get with this thing is from the amount of work it takes to take it out of the box and figure out how the heck it works.

5. igallop: Cost $250-$600: The igallop is meant to emulate the motion of riding a horse, in some bizarre fashion. As it turns out, sitting on a $12 stability ball is just as effective, but not quite as cool. The only silver lining is that this product is NOT sold by Tony Little….

6. The Lovehandler: Cost: If it’s more than free, I don’t care: Twisting and turning to reduce those unsightly love handles is the pitch for this gem. Has the CEO of this company ever heard that spot reduction IS NOT possible??

7. Red Exerciser: Cost: $55-$90: The last time I checked, this was called a chair…This is nothing more than a round seat with handles. It’s designed to work your core and there is some mumbo jumbo about pilates, but let’s be realistic….it’s a chair.

8. Neckline Slimmer: Cost: $10-$20: This also has the added benefit of being sold used on Amazon.com. Now you can have some stranger’s chin grease at no extra charge! According to the product creator, the neck and jaw muscles should be exercised with resistance just like every other muscle. “Regain your youth without surgery” is their slogan. It’s basically a spring loaded handheld device you press down on with your chin. I have also read multiple complaints about misleading information regarding shipping costs as well as being overcharged or sent additional products. What a shocker!

9. Sauna Suit: Cost: $10-$40: This has to be my least favorite of all due to the negative impact on your health. They are basically selling dehydration. If you want to sweat more, work harder. If you want to drop 15 pounds of water weight and gain 16 pounds back, buy this! Unless you are a wrestler and your coach is making you drop a bunch of weight quickly, forget it.

10. Shake Weights: Cost: $20: In just 6 minutes a day, you too can shape that body. Who wouldn’t want that? Apparently it also increases muscle activity by more than 300% over traditional weights. It was even mentioned on the Ellen DeGeneres Show so it MUST work, right? If you think this is at all possible, please stop reading this blog and never return……

11. Slendertones: Cost: $100-$150: This is another belt designed to provide Electronic Muscle Stimulation (EMS)-doesn’t that sound official?? This belt claims to work the outer and inner muscles of the core and is backed by 40 years of applied use in hospitals. I have to wonder just what type of “hospitals” they are used in..

12. Power Plates: Cost: $300-$7,000: This machine is actually getting quite a lot of attention these days. It’s popping up in gyms all across the country. Call me a skeptic, but I’m not a believer. The claim is that a 10 minute workout on a vibrating plate or disc can replace a traditional 60 minute workout.This is possible due to your muscles contracting up to 50 times each minute. Still not buying it… I have read that it is beneficial for people with multiple sclerosis, but for the general population, just use a BoSu for a great stability workout.

I realize that this article has focused entirely on the negative side of this business, but I just HATE, HATE, HATE frivolous fitness gimmicks. To be fair, all of these products have SOME redeeming qualities. If you want to buy any of them click HERE. Just kidding….

I also realize that if I keep this pace up, I may never be able to earn a living via this website because I will have eliminated all of my potential sponsors.

Push Ups For Sale

From the hundreds of exercises out there, push ups have to be one of my favorite. It’s a phenomenal exercise and can be done in dozens of variations. The best part is that it’s free, there is no equipment required, and can be done anywhere.

The push up is mainly a chest exercise, but also uses your triceps and front deltoids as synergists. Your biceps also play a role in stabilization as do your abdominals, obliques, and quadriceps. Done properly, it is an extremely effective exercise for building lean muscle, increasing bone density, and improving your cardiovascular system (just check your heart rate after doing 30 push ups in a row). From what I understand, doing a standard push up from your toes is the equivalent of pressing between 65-75% of your bodyweight. Doing this from your knees will reduce the load by about 50%.

Keeping proper form is an important part of its effectiveness. It’s crucial to keep your abdominals and glutes (butt) tight as you perform each rep. You want to keep your spine in a neutral position during the exercise. Of course, there are variations that will have you twisting, but those come after you have mastered the basic push up.  Also, make sure you breathe out every time you are pushing up. Holding your breath is a quick way to raise your blood pressure, get light headed, or pass out.  

Given that the push up requires no fancy gadgets or equipment, those looking to make money on this popular exercise have found ways to convince the public that they need them. The fitness market is HUGE and there is no shortage of fitness “experts” out there who will promote some useless piece of crap to earn a buck. One of the most frustrating things about being in this industry is seeing all the snake oil salesmen capitalizing on a hot trend or profitable market and selling something of very little value.

Below are several popular push up “necessities” that can be purchased just about anywhere:

 
These products are very profitable and to some degree may be useful, but in no way, shape, or form are they needed. Doing a push up on the ground, with your feet on a bench, or from your knees is all you really need to properly benefit from this exercise. The theory behind these 3 products is that they offer a greater range of motion and thus allowing  more muscle fibers to be recruited. This may be just fine for seasoned athletes, but for most of us it may ultimately just end up putting additional stress on the shoulder muscles which can lead to injury.
My advice is to stay away from these products and stick with the basics. The price tags are almost always higher than their value.

Fat Motivation

Move over Lance Armstrong, there’s a new breed of over-achiever and her name is Donna Simpson. Donna is a woman with unbridled passion, awe-inspiring determination, and has her eye on one goal and one goal only…..to join the Guinness Book of World’s Records as the fattest woman on the planet. Now that’s a lofty goal! Donna, currently at 602 pounds already holds the world’s record for the heaviest woman to give birth (only a measly 530 pounds). Imagine the joy of the lucky 30 hospital staff members who needed to assist with her C-section delivery. Damn you schedule……

Donna’s 150 pound husband is very supportive of her eating habits and wants nothing more that for her to reach her milestone goal. She simply needs to eat 12,000 calories each day and do absolutely nothing to keep gaining fat weight. Unfortunately, she often has to chase after  her 3 year old daughter which is burning up those much needed calories and setting her back.

They are also managing to spend over $3,000 each month on food, mostly baked goods (it’s hard to resist that box of donuts) and fast food. It’s not clear what her husbands line of work is, but Donna has been trying to earn food money by appearing on her website. Her website charges a fee to allow us the pleasure of watching her stuff her face full of greasy food! Apparantly she doubles the audiences viewing pleasure by wearing a bikini…..And no, I have not visited her site, nor will I ever (you just can’t take some things back).

Aside from her anti-healthy, pro-heart failure lifestyle, Donna insists that she is in perfectly fine health (aside from the Type 2 diabetes, of course). She is also an avid member of the “fat acceptance community” and is inspiring women all over to to adopt her motto of  “the bigger your butt is, the bigger belly you have, the sexier you are”.

Don’ get me wrong here, I’m not bashing overweight people at all. There are millions of overweight folks out there who are trying to make a positive change in their lifestyle and I applaud them. People like Donna can certainly do what they please to their bodies, I just don’t advocate the complete disregard for one’s health or the message it sends to the public.

I could rant about this for hours and break down all the heath related issues at hand here, but I won’t. The next time I update this post, it will be with her obituary.

The Importance Of Footwear When Exercising

Guest post By Terry N. Collins, C. Ped.

Anyone starting or continuing an exercise program needs at least one basic piece of equipment, a pair of shock absorbing, supportive and proper fitting athletic shoes. For exercise involving walking or running a pair of quality running shoes will satisfy this need. Those old basketball shoes, casual sneakers or other well-used “athletic” type shoes will not provide the cushioning and support required. You may see other athletic looking shoes in certain stores, but unless you know what you’re looking for, they may not provide the support and cushioning you need for your exercise routine.

Like the rest of our body, our feet often change over time. You may not be aware of your current foot size and may purchase shoes that are not the correct size. Many people have one foot that is longer or wider than the other foot. It is IMPORTANT to have your feet measured by someone that is trained to measure feet correctly.

LENGTH: It is common to fit shoes that are ½ to a full size longer than the measurement of the longest toe of the longest foot. A properly sized shoe will allow the foot to flex during running and walking so that the longest toe on each foot will not contact the front of the shoe. This helps to eliminate the possibility of blisters on the end of the toe, as well as allowing the foot to flex properly when running and walking.

WIDTH: The width of the foot is as important as the length. If your foot is wider than average, it may cause the mesh-upper of the shoe to extend over the side of the mid-sole. Wider width shoes may be required for you. Your shoe fitter will advise you about the proper length and width of the shoes you need. Most running/walking athletic shoes are available in a variety of lengths and widths. Athletic shoes are available for people with narrower feet as well as wider width feet.

CUSHIONING AND SHOCK ABSORPTION is provided by athletic shoes. This is just as important as proper length and width.  When walking for exercise, your feet will experience the force of three times your weight when your heel strikes the ground and your forefoot propels you forward. When running the number is 5 times your weight. For example, a 200 lbs man will experience the force of about 1,000 lbs on his feet when running. Quality athletic shoes that have ample cushioning will absorb much of that shock instead of your feet, ankles, knees, hips and back.

SUPPORT: Other components of a good running/athletic shoe will help to support your foot’s arch and heel. Arch supports of various heights and stiff heel counters are two devices built into athletic shoes to provide this type support.

If you run or walk for exercise and don’t have athletic shoes that provide cushioning, shock absorption and support required, you could experience shin splints, ankle pain, knee pain, back pain, blisters and a variety of other issues that may be caused by ill fitting and unsupportive shoes.

Selecting and fitting athletic shoes is a task that requires both knowledge of feet and knowledge of athletic shoes. When purchasing your athletic shoes you should seek the advice of personnel at a specialty running and walking shoe store. Shoe fitters at specialty athletic shoes stores are trained to ensure that you have the correct shoes for your level of exercise activity.

Here are some simple rules to follow when shopping for athletic shoes:

  • Shop for shoes in the afternoon, when your feet are at their maximum size. (They swell during the day.)
  • Wear the socks you normally wear with athletic shoes to assure the right fit.
  • Try on both shoes. Most people’s feet vary a bit in size from each other, so you should be sure the shoes fit your largest foot comfortably.
  • Look for materials that breathe.
  • Don’t shop by price alone. Prices may vary, but the comfort you feel from a pair of properly fit shoes ensures your purchase was well worth the price.

Terry Collins is an owner of the specialty shoe store If The Shoe Fits in Frederick. His website offers tips on running and marathon training as well as links to numerous running organizations.

Burn The Fat, Feed The Muscle Review

If you have not yet heard of this book (actually Ebook) which was written back in 2003 by Tom Venuto, then you need to read this review. If you’ve ever searched for fitness information products available online, then you probably have heard of this book since it’s the best selling nutrition and weight loss Ebook in history.

Being in the fitness industry for 13 years, I have read a TON of health and fitness related information, including books, magazines, newsletters, textbooks, Ebooks, and articles and this is BY FAR the best book on nutrition and fat loss I have ever read.

This review is completely honest about my opinion of this book. I am hoping one day to be able to earn a living (and quit my day job finally) through this website (via affiliate product marketing, sponsorship, and advertisements to name a few)  and I STRONGLY feel that if I compromise my integrity in order to make a sale, I will lose the trust of my readers and my business will ultimately fail. Therefore, any product review you read about on this site will be 100%  honest and will be written from personal experience.

The Review

Burn the Fat, Feed the Muscle is a book written about the proper methods to losing body fat and KEEPING it off. The author, Tom Venuto, is a natural body builder and fitness expert and has an excellent understanding of the science behind effective fat loss. To go directly to his site Click Here!

I first read Burn the Fat, Feed the Muscle in 2005 and was very impressed by the author’s writing style. It’s a very easy read and even those who are not in the fitness industry will have no problem understanding  his philosophies.

There are no fillers, ads, plugs, or page wasting redundant information in this book. This was written solely to help you understand how lose body fat and permanently keep it off. The best part is than you will learn why you are struggling with weight/fat loss and how to make the appropriate change.

As of 2010, I have read this book (all 300+ pages) at least 5 times and have come to truly appreciate the magnitude of this book. This book hits the nail right on the head with regards to giving you specific, actionable ideas, which are based on scientific facts and can be applied immediately.

Nutrition, as it relates to the impact on your physical condition, can be an overwhelming concept. Many people feel lost in a sea of diet book and so called nutrition experts and this book makes a point to dispel some of the popular myths out there. As a side note, I really hate the fact that it seems like any M.D. feels they are qualified to write a book on weight loss. Don’t get me wrong, having those initials after your name is a lot more of a credential that I will probably ever have, but many of these doctors don’t even specialize in nutrition. Anyway, that’s another article….

This book has really become my ‘bible’ for nutritional advice I offer my clients simply because it follows the exact principles about health fat loss that I believe in. I have never sold myself as an expert in the field of nutrition, but with the help of resources like this, I can give good, quality advice about improving your nutrition and reducing body fat.

The 17 chapters cover everything from determining your proper macro nutrient ratios (protein, carbs, fat), speeding up your metabolism, designing meal plans, the most effective fat burning cardio workouts, as well as a strength training program. For the Burn the Fat, Feed the Muscle download, Click Here!

Believe me, this is one product that you really should read if you are serious about changing your body composition or learning more about healthy eating . Now, there certainly are many other good, quality products out there if you know where to look. Unfortunately, there is MUCH more worthless garbage and often times it’s advice from some knucklehead that knows next to nothing about the topic. The Internet is a place of great creativity but also a place where original ideas are stolen, distorted, and claimed by lazy and/or greedy ‘writers’. Beware of this when shopping…

Thanks for reading my review and if you are considering purchasing this Ebook (it has a 60-day money back guarantee-no questions asked), please use this site and Click Here!

Forget Second Hand Smoke……

My article yesterday discussed the harmful effects of second hand smoke, especially on children. I came across this video, which was  on most major news channels this week, and couldn’t believe it.

Meet Ardi Rizal, a 2-year old boy from Indonesia. He likes playing with his friends, digging in the mud, and oh yea….smoking 40 cigarettes a day. How does this even happen? How is a little boy like this introduced to the wonderful world of smoking? I vote for excellent role models for parents. Apparantly, his parents have yet to hear of lung cancer or heart disease (or portion control).

You think your child throws a nasty temper tantrum when they don’t get what they want. How about a jumbo sized man-baby who is addicted to nicotine. This is just plain nuts!!!

This seems like a rarity, but I’m not so sure it isn’t happening much more frequently. The ironic part of all of this is that this kid will probably live to be 105 years old…..

In Other News

The world’s dirtiest city was revealed today and it’s Washington DC………just kidding.

It’s actually Linfen, China, a coal mining city in Shanxi province. As it turns out, residents don’t need to smoke since breathing in the polluted air is the equivalent of smoking 3 packs of cigarettes. Below is a picture of this lovely city. Forget sunny Hawaii, call China Air instead to book your flight here….

The Biggest Loser: ‘Reality’ Television?

First off, I want to make it clear that I am a fan of the show and have watched almost every season thus far. The show does an excellent job of teaching people how to make a change in your life and inspires confidence. Bob and Jillian are both phenomenal trainers and are a huge asset to the program.

There are, however, a number of issues I have with The Biggest Loser:

  • The contestants are in a fantasy setting where everything they do, 24 hours a day, is optimized for weight loss.
  • Their only ‘job’ is to lose weight. This is wonderful in the short-term, but is completely unrealistic in the real world.
  • Many of these folks are used to eating 3,000 or more calories per day. On the show, they are given 1,500. Dramatic drops in caloric intake will harm, rather than help, their metabolism.
  • The contestants are exercising between 4 and 5 hours each day. It’s unrealistic. Nobody has time to exercise that much when they get back home, nor is it safe to do so.
  • Most health professionals suggest a weight loss of 1-3 pounds per week at the most. It’s not uncommon for contestants to lose 15 to 25 pounds in a week. Where do you think this weight comes from?
  • Rebound weight is imminent. Many former contestants have gained a large portion of their pre-contest weight back.

An article in TIME Magazine featured Season 1 winner, Ryan Benson, who was asked about his strategy for winning. Ryan was quoted as saying ” I wanted to win so bad that the last ten days before the final weigh-in I didn’t eat one piece of solid food (READ: crash diet)! If you’ve heard of ’The Master Cleanse’, that’s what I did. It’s basically drinking lemonade made with water, fresh squeezed lemon juice, pure maple syrup, and cayenne pepper. The rules of the show said we couldn’t use any weight-loss drugs, well I didn’t take any drugs, I just starved myself. Twenty-four hours before the final weigh-in I stopped putting ANYTHING in my body, liquid or solid, then I started using some old high school wrestling tricks. I wore a rubber suit while jogging on the treadmill, and then spent a lot of time in the steam room (READ: dehydration). In the final 24 hours I probably dropped 10-13 pounds in just pure water weight. By the time of the final weigh-in, I was peeing blood.”

As a side note, Ryan, who had lost 122 pounds on the show, has gained 90 pounds back and actually gained 32 pounds in the first 5 days after the show by drinking water! Ryan also became depressed after the weight started coming back on, which I fear is probably quite prevalent among these contestants.

Of course, these tactics were used solely to win the $250,000 prize and most people would probably do the same. It is, of course, very unhealthy and kinda gross (peeing blood would freak me out!). The show does have testing procedures in place to uncover ’cheats’ such as these, but no violations have yet been found.

Another former contestant, Kelly Minner, has apparently managed to keep most of her weight off. However, it seems that she exercises 1 to 4 hours every day, 6 days per week. This is great if your lifestyle affords you that kind of time, but how many of us can actually do that?

The show has also received critisism from nutrition and weight-loss experts such as Kathleen Zelman, RD, who is the director of nutrition for WebMD and the WebMD Weight Loss Clinic. She writes ” The Biggest Loser competition might indeed result in big losses, but it defies all the professional wisdom about safe and effective weight loss. That’s because the contestants are not addressing lifestyle behaviors and eating habits that they need to change permanently, not just during a nine-week race. This approach is similar to a fad diet: You can lose weight on just about any diet, but when it’s over you gain the weight back-unless you’ve changed your behaviors.”

According the the National Weight Control Regisrty, “only 20% of dieters with a history of obesity sustain a loss of 10% of their body weight for a year or more.”

With all that said, this show has done great things for thousands of people. It’s inspired and motivated people all across the country to adopt a healthier lifestyle and/or begin exercising. There are certainly many contestants who have completely changed their lifestyle and have not had negative repercussions from the show.